We Never Knew Part 2: Sophie

“Dylan, we need to break up!” I said to my boyfriend after our nine-month relationship.

“Why baby? Did I do something wrong? Please don’t do this. I’ll to whatever it takes to keep this alive.”

“I’m sorry but it’s over. Goodbye Dylan.” I said as I walked out the door and called a taxi home.

I didn’t want my sister to know my secret of why I really broke up with Dylan so I rubbed my eyes to make them red and fake cried with I came home.

“Dylan broke my heart tonight!” I cried in my sister’s arms. Step one complete I thought because she totally bought it.

I should tell you my plan. I broke up with Dylan because I think I’m either bi-sexual or lesbian and I fell in love with someone else… my own sister Chloe.

A little while back, I was let out of school early and came home and I walked upstairs to my room. Before I opened the door, I heard moaning coming from our room. It sounded like my sister and she was saying something.

I opened the door a little bit and there was my sister fully naked spread eagle masturbating. I was about to leave but then she moaned my name.

“Oh Sophie yes please more more more!!!!”

What was even crazier was that I was getting turned on by it and before I knew it my hand was under my skirt touching myself to my masturbating sister.

“Yes Sophie you’re going to make me cum!!!!!!!!!”

Then she had a really powerful orgasm and was literally shaking in her bed. After that I slowly closed the door and went back downstairs.